“They don’t represent current operations,” says Ukiah-based consultant Andrew Jahn, lead author of the analysis reported in the September 2020 issue of San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science. Current operations at the State Water Project (SWP) and the Central Valley Project (CVP) can reverse flows in the Old and Middle rivers, diverting salmon on their way to the ocean towards the projects. Existing salmon loss estimates also fail to account for a likely Old River hotspot for predators, drawn to the influx of salmon and other fish near the two water projects. Evidence of this hotspot lies in the numerous acoustic tags from young salmon to be found in the sediment, which were presumably defecated by striped bass, as well as the fact that it is a popular spot for striped bass fishing. The hotspot is a two-kilometer stretch of Old River between the radial tide gates at the entrance of Clifton Court Forebay, which leads to the SWP, and the trash boom just before the CVP. “The state says ‘our impacts begin at the radial gates’ and federal officials say ‘our impacts being at the trash boom,’ ” Jahn explains. “But you know predators wouldn’t concentrate upstream at the bend of Old River without a draw.” Improving estimates of salmon loss in the south Delta will require new studies, the researchers say; Jahn envisions releasing tagged fish upstream of the predation hotspot. In the interim, Jahn and co-author William Kier, a San Rafael-based consultant, recommend incorporating data collected since the 1970s. “We could use the data we have better,” Jahn says.

Pearls in the ocean of information that our reporters didn’t want you to miss
State and federal water projects in the south Delta near Tracy, California. Credit: Virginia Macintosh.
 

Current estimates of young salmon lost to the south Delta pumps are based on a smattering of studies from the 1970s and should be updated, according to a new analysis.

"They don't represent current operations," says Ukiah-based consultant Andrew Jahn, lead author of the analysis reported in the September 2020 issue of San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science. Current operations at the State Water Project (SWP) and the Central Valley Project (CVP) can reverse flows in the Old and Middle rivers, diverting salmon on their way to the ocean towards the projects. Existing salmon loss estimates also fail to account for a likely Old River hotspot for predators, drawn to the influx of salmon and other fish near the two water projects. Evidence of this hotspot lies in the numerous acoustic tags from young salmon to be found in the sediment, which were presumably defecated by striped bass, as well as the fact that it is a popular spot for striped bass fishing. The hotspot is a two-kilometer stretch of Old River between the radial tide gates at the entrance of Clifton Court Forebay, which leads to the SWP, and the trash boom just before the CVP. "The state says 'our impacts begin at the radial gates' and federal officials say 'our impacts being at the trash boom,' " Jahn explains. "But you know predators wouldn't concentrate upstream at the bend of Old River without a draw." Improving estimates of salmon loss in the south Delta will require new studies, the researchers say; Jahn envisions releasing tagged fish upstream of the predation hotspot. In the interim, Jahn and co-author William Kier, a San Rafael-based consultant, recommend incorporating data collected since the 1970s. "We could use the data we have better," Jahn says.

About the author

Robin Meadows is an independent science journalist in the San Francisco Bay Area. She covers water and climate change adaptation for Estuary News, is the water reporter for the Bay Area Monitor, and contributes to Bay Nature, Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, PLOS Research News and Water Deeply. Robin also enjoys hiking and photography.

Related Posts

Climate change is heating, salinizing, and expanding the San Francisco Estuary, a review of nearly 200 scientific studies concludes.

Sea level rise, changing snow and rainfall patterns, and warmer waters are some of the changes already observed in the Estuary and expected to continue through the rest of the century as greenhouse gas concentrations rise. Changes to water are at the heart of the documented and further expected impacts;...

Groundwater pumped from subsided islands back into Delta channels through 200 or more active outfalls can be laden with excess nitrogen transported from island soils, report the authors of a new study.

The Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta contains more than 50 peat islands. Most have subsided—some as much as three meters — as a result of drainage for farming, and must maintain artificial water tables below the land surface via managed pumping. According to researchers from the University of California at Santa Cruz...

Researchers are applying a novel genetic technique as part of the development of an annual estimate for the number of juvenile spring-run Chinook salmon entering the Delta.

The technique, spearheaded by geneticist Melinda Baerwald from the California Department of Water Resources, allows researchers to accurately distinguish young spring-run salmon from other runs by targeting DNA sequences specific to these fish.   In a paper published in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science, lead authors Baerwald and Peter...